Thursday, February 12, 2015

#YouTube #Gotitwrong

I was just playing some music on YouTube and a funny thing happened. Mid-playlist, there came on one of those ubiquitous, unnecessary ads. I was surprised it was an ad for Santoor. Talc, or some such. But what really got me was that the ad was in Gujarati. “Yes, I have recently moved to Gujarat, YouTube, but how did you know that?” was what I was thinking. 

I had recently booked flight tickets to Ahmedabad as well as several other train and bus tickets for my travel last week, and YouTube had, through its convenient link to Google’s databases, sniffed out my itinerary and deciphered, quite correctly, that I must be living in Gujarat now.  All snooty, futuristic, uber-modern-digital-marketing aside, “You got it WRONG, YouTube. There were so many ways for you to get it right, but you didn’t.  

I may be living in Gujarat, but that does not automatically imply that I know the language! As a matter of fact, I don’t! 

You could have used the information you so secretively (or perhaps, not-so-secretively: who knows what agreements you have both got me to “Agree to” over the years) acquired from your parent’s coffers to hit me with perhaps an ad of a product type that suited my travel needs. Clearly I had been doing rather a lot. Or, if you really wanted to use the Gujarati angle, try hitting me with, say, a Gujarati brand ad, but in Hindi. I was in Delhi for nearly 7 months. Did you not know that from Facebook? 
Even if you didn't, Hindi is fairly commonly understood in Gujarat. If you were trying to target a lower, and hence, more massive slab of the SEC pyramid using the regional language to relate to me better with me (Santoor does presumably target a lower SEC consumer base), you got it wrong anyway for two reasons: that’s not my SEC slab and the Gujarati tongue holds no significance for me. 

But, even if you weren't, you would be providing more of a “value-added” service to your ad clients by tailoring your technique to select an ad for me that I could understand. That would be more relevant to me, the viewer, than an ad that I couldn't understand. If you like, show me an Adani ad; I’ll even take that as “relevant media placement”. At least, the Adanis ARE from Gujarat. As such, they have great presence around the city. Supplementing their out of home media plan with digital reach would contribute to Adani’s brand building effort. I, the target in this case, am not in fact an immediate prospect as a source of sales, or income for them. But there’s such a thing as salience, which is the necessary first step for brand building. You, as a front-runner in the digital marketing space, ought to be able to provide to your clients this at the very least. With a Gujarati Santoor ad, you got it all wrong.”


It’s funny. It is. J